| The Battle for Leningrad, 1941-1944 (Modern War Studies) |  | Author: David M. Glantz Publisher: University Press of Kansas Category: Book
List Price: $39.95 Buy New: $20.00 as of 9/8/2010 04:59 CDT details You Save: $19.95 (50%)
New (12) Used (30) Collectible (4) from $15.29
Seller: feld_grau Rating: 12 reviews Sales Rank: 783,542
Media: Hardcover Edition: First Edition Pages: 704 Number Of Items: 1 Shipping Weight (lbs): 2.6 Dimensions (in): 8.8 x 6.9 x 1.9
ISBN: 0700612084 Dewey Decimal Number: 940.5421721 EAN: 9780700612086 ASIN: 0700612084
Publication Date: November 2002 Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
| |
| Similar Items:
| |
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description The German siege and Soviet defense of Leningrad in World War II was an epic struggle in an epic war, a drama of heroism and human misery unmatched in the annals of modern warfare. While innumerable writers have dealt at length with the besieged city itself, David Glantz provides for the first time the definitive military history of the conflict waged beyond the city's borders. One of the first major Soviet cities threatened by the German blitzkrieg, Leningrad was as much a symbolic target as it was a strategic one for Adolf Hitler, who fully expected the birthplace of the Russian Revolution to be reduced to rubble quickly and with ease. The Red Army's ferocious defense of the city, however, made that impossible. Glantz digs deep to recount the full story of how these two military giants bludgeoned each other for nearly three years with a relentless barrage of offensives and counter-offensives designed to crush one another, in horrendous weather and a harsh terrain and with staggering loss of life on both sides. His richly detailed history shows how battles and campaigns were conceived, engaged, and resolved-including a half dozen or more "forgotten battles" that took place during the blockade. He explains how the struggle for Leningrad impacted other theaters of operation along the Eastern Front, eventually forcing the Germans into their long and costly retreat back toward Berlin. Glantz also provides insights into conditions within the city, adding new details to the horrors of the siege; sheds new light on partisan warfare in the countryside surrounding Leningrad; and corrects many errors found in earlier works. Based on an unparalleled access to Russian archival sources and going far beyond the military aspects of such renowned works as Harrison Salisbury's 900 Days, Glantz's book is a testament to the nearly two million Russians who lost their lives during the Leningrad conflict and confirms his status as the preeminent authority on the Russian military experience in World War II. This book is part of the Modern War Studies series.
|
| Customer Reviews:
Showing reviews 1-5 of 12
a detailed analysis of the battle for Leningrad November 25, 2002 1. (Littleton, CO United States) 34 out of 36 found this review helpful
The opening chapters of the Battle for Leningrad describe the desperate counterattacks that the Russians made against the German invaders. According to Glantz these attacks stalled the advance of the German armies and prevented Leningrad and Moscow from capture. The second part of the book descibes the failed Soviet counteratttacks to relieve the city. Glantz believes that these attacks failed because they were dispersed and the Russians falied to combined artillery,air, and infantry effectively. The final section of the book details the lifting of the seige of Leningrad and how the Russians managed to operate more effectively by using deception and cordinating with other fronts in conducting offensive operations. However the Russian adavnce was slow because the terrain around Leningrad does not favor the massive tank armies that Russians usually employed on their offensives, but rather they had to rely upon the infantry to achieve a breakthrough. Glantz concludes his book by stating that although the Leningrad Front was a minor front it made the Germans commit ground forces to Leningrad that could have used to capture Moscow and Stalingrad. This is a book is a detailed military history of the battle and I would reccomend this book to military history buffs, but not your average reader since he or she might get bored and confused with the different army groups and fronts. This book emphasizes the military operations and glosses over the civilian suffering during the seige of Leningrad. If one is interested in the civilian view of the seige of Leningrad. I would reccomend "The People's War," edited by Robert W.Thurston.
Highly detailed analysis January 17, 2006 T. Kunikov (United States) 1 out of 1 found this review helpful
As with most of the David Glantz's books this is a highly detailed analysis of the situation Leningrad found itself in throughout the Second World War on the Eastern Front. At times day by day accounts of unit movements and operations will make it a bit difficult to follow what was happening but it shouldn't take away from the fact that so much was going on from 1941 when the siege of the city began to 1944 when it was finally broken. Interestingly enough on my last visit to Russia (summer of 2005) I was in St. Petersburg and our guide told us that Stalin did not give any help to the city rather letting them hold on with the forces available on hand. Rather odd to think this is true when taking account of the 'Road of Life' over Lake Ladoga and the amount of reinforcements that were being brought in. This book will put that myth to rest. There were countless attempts to relieve the city and keep the Germans pinned, losses were high on both sides and to a large degree much of the front was static warfare. This book is a dense study of practically each and every operation undertaken by the Red Army and the results which they brought. It is given from the Soviet point of view as are all Glantz books but that shouldn't take away from the fact that it is highly factual with many sources including archival to back up everything that is presented. A good companion to this book might be "Hitler's Spanish Legion" which served in the region this book is focused on, that book will the reader a greater understanding of what was happening with individual soldiers on the front line from the German side (although these are Spanish soldiers and the book is somewhat biased for the German side, so a nice rounding out effect to Glantz's work). The reader will understand how devastating round the clock attacks were for the German Army and how eventually the enemy was beaten (to a degree by attrition and to a degree by other means).
best book on this conflict written April 30, 2008 Michael Buck (wisconsin, usa) This book is absolutely a treasure trove of info. Everything, EVERYTHING on all aspects of this campaign, militarily, are here. The wealth of knowledge gleaned from a David Glantz book is always welcome, but in Leningrad it reaches new highs. This is certainly not for the beginner or for someone interested in flowery prose, but for sheer detail there is no other book on the Battle of Leningrad that comes within 100 miles of this. It was nice too, and a bit surprising, to see Glantz delve into the aspects of the siege on the general population of Leningrad and actually print civilian survivor's tales. What went on in Leningrad is without equal as far as sieges go. Two million dead in just three years, much of the inner city in ruins, starvation and disease rampant in an ill prepared population, callousness towards the population from both Hitler and Stalin. This is an absolute must read for students of the battle. Nothing else even comes close. Thanks again to David Glantz on another stupendous work, and here's hoping that his upcoming book on Stalingrad comes out soon. That will be eagerly anticipated indeed. Great work David Glantz!
An Excellent Account of the Siege and Liberation of Leningrad December 24, 2009 Dave Schranck (Anaheim Ca) Once again, Mr Glantz has delivered a jam packed account of another important campaign of WWII. The action covers, in the German sector, the beginning of Barbarossa in June 1941 and goes to April 1944 when the Russians had liberated Leningrad giving it access to Moscow by rail and pushing the Germans back to the prepared defensive line called Panther.
The book is divided into three parts. The first part is the Opening assault that takes AGN past the Baltics, Lake Pskov, Luga, Novgorod and Kingisepp by the end of September 1941. For the rest of the year, Leeb tries to break into the city but fails each time. When Hitler transfers important outfits to AGC for their Operation Typhoon, Leeb is forced to stop the offensive and lay siege to the city.
Part two includes the next two years when the blockade is in place and the Germans try to get the city to surrender while the local Russian Fronts try to break the strangle hold. At first the Russians make little progress but after repeated attempts they slowly gain momentum and by the start of 1944 have the initiative.
The last part involves the major Russian offensive that breaks the blockade around Leningrad and pushes the Germans back to the Panther Line by April 1944. The defeat of the Finns is also covered.The Siniavino series of battles were especially well covered. Battle coverage also includes partisan influence for the three years. The misery of the civilians trapped in Leningrad is also discussed.
As usual the operational detail is impressive. The tactical and strategic elements of each battle is given along with brief analysis, allowing the reader to understand the significance of the actions taken by both sides. The Russian side is favored but the German coverage is adequate.
Mr Glantz must have thought going past April 1944 beyond the limits of the liberation of Leningrad. That's too bad for there was considerable action for the rest of the year when the Russians pushed the Germans beyond the Panther line to the Wendish and Segewold lines.
In addition to the narrative are 18 maps. The maps are good but all cover the large regional conflict area. The book could've been improved by adding additional maps showing the small area of individual battles.
There are also photos and information tables to add to the reading experience. There is also an extensive Appendix that includes a detailed Order of Battle, important war documents and statistics of the campaign.
Overall this is the best book on Leningrad that I've read but I would like to suggest reading Steven Newton's "Retreat from Leningrad" for it adds coverage to the latter months of 1944 as well as some beneficial analysis.
For Specialists Only! June 16, 2003 David W. Nicholas (Montrose, CA USA) 22 out of 23 found this review helpful
David M. Glantz is a retired army officer who spent most of the latter part of his career studying the Soviet army. He founded and then headed the army's study group that concentrated on the Soviet army (with the fall of Communism the center now devotes itself to the Russian army, and associated armed forces of nearby countries). He's now retired, and has been producing a book every two or three years on the Soviet army during the Second World War. The present volume is in many ways his most ambitious, an attempt to retell the whole of the battle of Leningrad, from the initial German attempts to capture the city through the lifting of the blockade almost three years later.Glantz has several strengths as a historian, and a few weaknesses. His principal strength, and this can't be overstated, is his access to Soviet archives that no one else has gotten into since the war ended. One of his previous books, Zhukov's Greatest Defeat, recounts a large battle on the Eastern front in late 1942 that doesn't appear in many histories of World War II, because the Soviets successfully suppressed knowledge of it. There aren't any whoppers of that magnitude here, but there is a wealth of detail concerning operations, intentions, and forces that hasn't appeared elsewhere. On the other hand, Glantz isn't Hemingway, or even Harrison Salisbury. His prose is rather wooden, and workmanlike, fine for retelling a story of a battle, but not much as literature. It's OK for the first 300 pages, but this book stretches to 470 pages of text, and it gets a little wearing. In other words, if you aren't *very* interested in the subject, I would recommend going elsewhere. On the flip side, if you *are* interested, there's more information here than you'll find anywhere else, and it's clearly presented and intelligently analyzed. As an aside, you'll notice that all of the references above are to Glantz as a historian of the Soviet side of things. There are (of course) references to the Germans here, and to their dilemmas and opportunities, but the emphasis is on the Soviets. In most instances, the book only tells you what the Germans are doing to provide context for the actions of the Soviet army. He does provide a brief history of the city prior to the war, and some account of the privations of the citizens of the city during the war, but this has been done elsewhere, and better. I suppose if he didn't provide anything like this, he'd be criticized for its absence, but frankly it seemed a bit out of place. Given that, this is one of the best books on the Eastern Front to appear in a good long while, and if you're as interested in this field as I am, it's a worthwhile addition to your library.
Showing reviews 1-5 of 12
|
|
|
Copyright © 2009 Southeast Asian Culture and Education Foundation
| |